Skip to main content

Interrogate & Evaluate Resources — Authority

What is Authority? An Initial Exploration

Read through the definitions of authority given by the dictionary. "On the Internet, no one knows you're a dog."

Here a few characteristics that build authority: 

  • Credentials of the author
  • The inclusion of evidence
  • Engagement with other viewpoints
  • Personal experience

Different types of authority:

  • Societal position (like a judge)
  • Expertise (education & experience)
  • Experiential (eyewitness, lived experience)

Look over one of your sources, and select one that is of interest to you. Look at your source, considering these questions:

  • Which definition or types of authority applies in the information world?
  • What kind of authority does your source have?
  • What kind of evidence or signals does it use to support or shore up its authority?
  • What kind of authority do you want to use for your project?

Authority

You get to be an authority yourself. While you're reading something, take notes. What are their qualifications? Are the experts' claims backed up by evidence? Do the points they are making seem to follow logically? 

Keep in mind, expertise is usually specialized & narrow. An expert in one area is not usually an expert in all areas. It makes a lot of sense when you think about it: most experts specialize in one field, because of the time and energy it takes to engage deeply with a certain subject. It's the reason that a hospital will have someone who specializes in brain surgery and someone who specializes in heart surgery. 

So, keep asking yourself: What makes this person qualified to speak on this topic? Are they respected/trusted by other experts?